facebook pixel Smoke Detectors Buying Guide | HomeTips
Select Page

Smoke Detectors Buying Guide

A expert guide to various types of smoke detectors and their features, buying smoke detectors, locating them in your home, and installing properly.

Smoke detector emits an ear-piercing alarm at the first sign of smoke. Be sure to test it periodically by pressing the test button.Bertold Werkmann / Shutterstock.com

Smoke detector emits an ear-piercing alarm at the first sign of smoke. Be sure to test it periodically by pressing the test button.

Every year in the United States, more than 3,500 people die in home fires and another 18,000 are injured. Additionally, house fires cost almost $8 billion in property damage annually. Many victims do not die of burns but rather smoke inhalation, because fires often occur at night when victims are asleep.

Smoke detectors are the best way to prevent these catastrophic results. The risk of dying from a home not protected by a smoke detector is twice that of a protected home. Of course, it is essential that the detector is operational: Approximately 95% of U.S. homes have at least one smoke detector, yet 20 percent of fire fatalities occur in homes with broken or disabled detectors.

smoke and carbon monoxide detectorFirst Alert

Best-selling hardwired smoke detector also warns of carbon monoxide and has a battery backup.

A smoke detector stands guard around the clock, and when it first senses smoke, it sounds an alarm, often buying a family the precious time it takes to escape. The most common alarm is a beeping noise that is piercing and persistent enough to alert homeowners to danger.

Other types of alarms include a voice detector, which has verbal commands pre-recorded in addition to an alarm. Examples of the pre-recorded commands are ”Fire, get out!” or “Smoke alert!” or Low-battery alert.” One version of this type may even have a parent’s voice pre-recorded (studies indicate that children are more likely to respond quickly to a parent’s voice).

Strobe detectors are smoke alarms that are designed to meet the needs of the hearing-impaired. These smoke alarms use strobe lights that flash or vibrate to alert those who are unable to hear standard smoke alarms. There are also detectors that respond with tactile stimulation such as bed shaking.

Battery or Hardwired?

Most smoke detectors are battery powered, but some, particularly those installed during house construction, are hard-wired into a home’s electrical system. Most hard-wired smoke detectors run on line voltage (household current) and have a battery backup in case a fire knocks out the house’s electrical power. Battery-powered smoke detectors are easier to install. Smoke detector batteries insider both battery-operated and hard-wired smoke detectors last approximately 6 months. When they need replacing, the detector will chirp every minute or so to indicate that the batteries are expiring.

The main problem with battery-powered smoke detectors is that people don’t maintain them. All battery-operated detectors are supposed to signal a low battery, but you have to make sure they’re working; newer models won’t close if the battery is removed. New lithium battery models last up to 10 years; the entire unit is disposable.

Types of Smoke Detectors

There are many brands of smoke detector on the market, but they all fall under two basic types—ionization chamber smoke detectors and photoelectric smoke detectors. Both types have two basic parts: a sensor to sense the smoke and a very loud electronic horn to alert people.

dual smoke carbon detectorKidde (Firex)

Top-rated smoke and carbon monoxide detector uses both ionization and photoelectric technologies, and it features voice commands to let you know what’s wrong.

Ionization detectors use a radioactive source that produces electrically charged molecules (ions). This sets up an electrical current within the detector chamber. When smoke enters the chamber, it attaches to the ions and reduces the flow of electrical current, which sets off the alarm. Ionization detectors are better at detecting the smaller amounts of smoke produced by fast, flaming fires.

Photoelectric detectors use an optical detector sensor (a photo beam) and go off when smoke from a smoldering fire is dense enough to deflect that beam of light.

Dual detectors Because homeowners cannot predict the type of fire that might start, a combination smoke detector—called a dual-sensor smoke alarm—is actually the wisest choice.

Smoke Detector Features

Depending upon quality of smoke detectors, some also offer:

• A remote-control mute button that can be linked to a television remote control to silence nuisance alarms.

• Safety lights to provide illumination during an alarm.

• Silence buttons that will quiet the alarm for a few minutes at a time. Detectors with this feature are commonly placed in kitchens.

• Transmission of a signal to a central monitoring station as part of a security alert system.

• Intercommunication of hardwired smoke detectors that guarantees if one alarm in the house goes off, they all go off. Even if the fire is detected in the basement, people upstairs will hear an alarm.

Addressable Smoke Detectors

Addressable smoke detection systems provide knowledge of the exact location and status of every device. The alarm decision is generally made by control equipment rather than an individual detection device.

Addressable system features include:

• The alarm can be investigated before a fire service is called.

• The system can tell you which device needs maintenance.

• Each detector is uniquely identified, and the exact location of each unit is displayed at the fire control panel.

• Any cut wires or short circuits do not generate nuisance alarms.

• Each sensor can be adjusted to its own unique environment.

• Nuisance alarms are less likely because the system uses multi-sensor detection

• Many incorporate strobe lights as a means of alerting the hearing impaired.

Smoke-CO Detectors

Nest Protect combination CO detector and smoke alarmNest Protect

Nest Protect combination CO detector and smoke alarm connects with you mobile phone via Wi-Fi.

Combination detectors are gaining in popularity because they combine smoke and carbon monoxide detection. They are available as CO and ionization alarms and CO and photoelectric alarms. By purchasing these combo alarms, you would have fewer alarms to place in your home (except that many CO alarms mount in the typical wall outlet placed low on the wall while the optimum smoke alarm placement is on or near the ceiling).

A hugely popular new innovation is the Nest Protect Smoke & Carbon Monoxide Alarm. When connected to Wi-Fi, this sends an alert to your mobile phone if the alarm is activated or the batteries run low. A voice actually tells you whether the problem is smoke or CO and where it is occurring. The connection is operated through a companion app on your phone. The carbon monoxide sensor has a 10-year life. You can buy both battery operated and hard-wired models.

How Smoke Detectors Work

©Don Vandervort, HomeTips

Smoke Detector Parts Diagram

The inner workings of a smoke detector include three main parts: the sensing chamber, a loud horn, and a battery (or house voltage power source). A test button lets you know if the battery, sensor and alarm are working properly. Batteries should be replaced yearly, on a regular schedule.

Standard smoke detectors work by ionization; some use a photoelectric cell. With ionization, a tiny amount of radioactive material conducts electricity through the air between two electrodes.

When smoke upsets the current, the alarm sounds. Photoelectric models use a small beam of light. Smoke causes the light to disperse and, when it does, the alarm begins to bleat its warning.

Some models sound false alarms when they detect kitchen cooking smoke or high bathroom humidity. It’s best not to put them within 20 feet of kitchens, garages, furnaces, hot water heaters, or within 10 feet of a bathroom. Also avoid drafty locations.

Where to Put Smoke Detectors

It is common to have one smoke detector per floor, but the U.S. Fire Administration recommends the installation of both an ionization chamber detector and a photoelectric detector or one dual-sensor alarm per floor. Choosing one battery-operated and one hardwired detector ensures your home is fully protected because it is far less likely that two detectors will be inoperable at the same time.

©Don Vandervort, HomeTips

Smoke detectors should be located on each level of a house and outside each sleeping area (one hallway detector can serve several bedrooms).


To be on the safest side, place one detector in every bedroom, and at least one on every level of the home, including the basement and attic. In addition, every home should have at least one working fire extinguisher.

Because smoke rises, most smoke detectors are mounted on the ceiling or on a wall near the ceiling. Ceiling-mounted detectors should be placed 4 inches away from any wall at the highest part of the ceiling, with one exception: If you have a cathedral ceiling, do not place detectors at the high point of the ceiling, nor in a corner, because these are dead air spaces; instead, place detectors at the next highest level. Wall-mounted detectors should be placed on the wall several inches, but no more than a foot, from the ceiling.

Detectors should be several horizontal feet away from a heating or cooling register, window, corner of a room, edge of a ceiling fan’s sweep, and any ducts or doors to a kitchen or bathroom (because cooking smoke and bathroom steam can cause false alarms). They should also be placed as far away as possible from combustion sources such as oil- or gas-fired furnaces, space heaters, clothes dryers, and water heaters.

In basements, a smoke detector should be placed at the bottom of the stairs and an additional detector near any sleeping areas in a finished basement.

If you are unsure where to place your smoke detectors, contact your local fire department or a state building inspector for assistance.

Smoke Detectors for High Ceilings

Beam smoke detectors are uniquely suited for protecting open areas with high ceilings where other methods of smoke detection are difficult to install and maintain. The beam of the detector senses a reduction in the signal of the unit, and works effectively on both smoky and fast-flaming fires.

Beam detectors come dual-ended and single-ended, with the single-ended beam detectors the easier to install. Alignment is accomplished through an optical sight and two-digit signal-strength meter incorporated into the unit.

The most basic unit consists of a transmitter/receiver unit and a reflector. When smoke enters the area between the unit and the reflector, it causes a reduction in the signal. If the smoke level reaches the predetermined threshold, the alarm is activated.

Other, more costly models have sensitivity adjustments and testing features.

How to Install a Smoke Detector

If your smoke detectors are hardwired, you will need to have a qualified electrician do the initial installation. All you need for battery-powered detectors is a screwdriver; some brands are even self-adhering and stick to the wall or ceiling where they are placed.

For all smoke-alarm installations, be sure you follow the manufacturer’s instructions because there are differences between brands.

If you are uncomfortable standing on a ladder, ask a relative or friend for help. Some fire departments will install a smoke alarm in your home for you. You can find out whether your fire department offers this service by calling them on a non-emergency telephone number.

About Don Vandervort
Author Image
Don Vandervort has developed his expertise for more than 30 years, as Building Editor for Sunset Books, Senior Editor at Home Magazine, author of more than 30 home improvement books, and writer of countless magazine articles. He appeared for 3 seasons on HGTV’s “The Fix,” and served as MSN’s home expert for several years. Don founded HomeTips in 1996.

Join the Conversation