Select Page

Cost-Effective Cabinet Renovation: Refinishing vs. Refacing

If you’d like to update and improve the look of your kitchen without the high costs associated with buying and installing new cabinets, then refinishing or refacing them is a decidedly simpler, less expensive approach.
cabinet refinishing refacing

Refinishing involves removing the existing cabinet doors and drawer faces, sanding or stripping off the old finish, and applying a new paint or stain to the doors, drawer faces, and cabinets.

Refacing (or resurfacing) involves replacing the old doors and drawer faces with brand-new doors and drawer faces. The cabinets are then veneered and stained, or painted, to match the new components.

In both cases, the existing cabinets remain intact. As a result, refinishing or refacing cabinets is more affordable, quicker, and less disruptive than replacing cabinets.

Kitchen Evaluation

Before deciding to either refinish or reface the cabinets, make sure your cabinets are suitable for either of these upgrade options. Here’s a quick checklist to determine whether your cabinets are a good candidate for refinishing or refacing.

For refinishing, all components must be in good condition, including the doors, drawer faces, and cabinets. For refacing, it’s okay if the doors and drawer faces are damaged or outdated because they’ll be replaced.

No matter which option you choose, the cabinets and drawer boxes will remain when refinishing or refacing, so they must be in sound condition and good working order. Use this checklist to determine if your cabinets are a good candidate for refinishing or refacing.

  • Inspect the inside of each cabinet for signs of structural damage, such as cracked side panels or loose joints. Poke around inside the cabinet with an awl or pocketknife. If you discover any soft, spongy areas, that could be an indication of wood rot or water damage.
  • Be sure the upper cabinets are securely fastened to the walls and to each other.
  • Check base cabinets for water damage, too, especially under the sink. The bottom of the cabinets should be firm and flat, not sagging or dislodged.
  • The face frames, if any, must be firmly attached to the cabinets, and their edges and corners should be smooth and flat. Small cracks and holes can be filled with wood putty, but face frames that are split in two must be replaced.
  • Be sure that all fixed shelves are securely attached and not cracked, loose, or warped.
  • Check each drawer to ensure it rolls smoothly, opens fully and closes completely. Remove the drawers from the cabinets and inspect the structural integrity of each one. The corner joints should be tight and strong. The drawer bottoms must be secured within the drawer box and not cracked or sagging badly.
  • The drawer slides—whether made of metal or wood—must be firmly attached and in sound condition. Check the slides for loose or missing fasteners, and damaged or worn-out parts.

Once you’ve assessed your cabinets and determined they’re in good shape, you can consider these two cabinet updating options.

Cabinet Refinishing

The amount of time and effort it takes to refinish kitchen cabinets is often determined by two key factors: Whether the new finish will be stain or paint and the complexity of the design on the doors

Stain is brushed-on to cabinet doors and excess is wiped off with a clean cotton cloth.

Staining requires more prep work than painting, especially if you’re changing the stain color. Door style matters because raised-panel Colonial-style doors with arched upper rails take longer to refinish than simple, flat-panel Shaker-style doors.

Regardless of other factors, the first step to refinishing cabinets is to remove the cabinet doors and unscrew the drawer faces from the drawer boxes. If the drawer faces are an integral part of the drawer box, then pull the entire drawer from the cabinet. Next, remove all the hardware, including knobs, pulls, and hinges.

Clean the doors, drawer faces and cabinets with a solution of one part trisodium phosphate (TSP) and four parts water. Pour the solution into a planter mister and spray it onto the surfaces. Scrub with a scourging sponge, then wipe the surfaces dry.

Next, determine how much of the old finish you need to remove. If you’re re-staining the kitchen, then you must sand the doors, drawer faces and cabinets down to bare wood. (For the cabinets, you only need to sand the face frames and any exposed end panels.)

The best tools for sanding are an orbital finishing sander, a random-orbit sander, a hand-sanding block, and a sanding sponge, which conforms to rounded edges and other irregular shapes. An electric contour or detail sander, which has interchangeable pads, can also prove useful, but isn’t absolutely necessary. Note that you can also use a chemical stripper to remove the old finish, but sanding is less toxic and messy.

Start with 100-grit sandpaper and then sand again with progressively finer 120- and 150-grit sandpaper. Once the wood is sanded smooth, rub or brush on the stain, allow it to soak into the wood for 10 minutes or so, and then—and this is important—wipe off the excess stain with a clean cotton cloth. If the color is too light, immediately apply a second coat, but again, remember to wipe off any excess. Repeat until you achieve the desired darkness.

Allow the stain to dry overnight, then use a foam brush to apply a coat of satin polyurethane varnish. Let the first coat dry and then sand lightly with 220-grit sandpaper. Wipe off the sanding dust and apply a second coat of varnish.

Reinstall the hinges and hang the doors back onto the cabinets. You can also reinstall the old knobs and pulls, but for a newer updated look, consider replacing them with new hardware.

If you’re going to paint the cabinets, start by removing all the hardware and unscrewing the doors and drawer faces. Then, scrub clean all surfaces with the diluted TSP solution, as mentioned above.

Next, sand the doors, drawer faces and cabinet face frames and end panels. However, for painting, you don’t have to sand down to bare wood. In most cases, you only need to sand away loose, dirty paint. If you do sand down to bare wood in some areas, that’s fine, but just be sure to “feather” the paint around the bare spot to create a smooth transition with the surrounding painted surface.

Wipe away the sanding dust with a tack rag or damp cloth and then apply a high-quality primer/sealer. Allow the primer to dry and then brush or spray on a coat of 100 percent acrylic latex semi-gloss paint. Wait for the paint to thoroughly dry and then sand lightly with 220-grit sandpaper. Wipe off the sanding dust and apply a second paint coat.

It’s worth noting that while cabinet refinishing is within the capabilities of experienced DIYers, most home improvement stores offer professional cabinet refinishing services, which include a free in-home consultation and written price quote.

Cabinet Refacing

As mentioned earlier, cabinet refacing consists of installing all new doors and drawer faces, so your first step is to go shopping. If you’re planning to install the new components yourself, you can buy them from a local cabinetmaker or an online retailer. For professional design help and installation, visit the kitchen showroom at your local home-improvement store.

Cabinet refacing includes the installation of all new hardware, including door hinges, pulls, and knobs.

New cabinet doors and drawer faces are available in literally dozens of sizes, styles, colors, and wood species in both stain and paint finishes. All you need to do is write down the size and number of each door and drawer face, and then select the style, color, and finish you’d like. The items usually ship within two or three weeks.

If you choose a stained finish, the existing cabinet face frames and exposed end panels will be refaced with wood veneer and then stained to match the new doors and drawer faces. If you install painted doors and drawers, the face frames and end panels will be painted to match. Just be sure to clean and sand the surfaces prior to veneering or painting.

To hang the new doors, start by screwing each hinge mounting plate to the inside of the cabinet. Next, screw the hinges into the pre-bored holes in the back of the door. Hold the door up to the cabinet and align the door hinges with the mounting plates. Secure each hinge with the provided screws. Adjust the hinges so that the door hangs plumb and level with an even gap all around. Note that cabinet refacing packages typically include new door hinges but not doorknobs and drawer pulls, which you’ll have to purchase separately.

Fasten the drawer faces by driving screws through from the inside of the drawer box. Be sure the screws aren’t so long that they’ll poke through the new drawer face.

cabinet refacing

Cabinet refacing companies offer doors in dozens of styles, colors, and wood species.

For an average-size kitchen, professional cabinet refinishing will cost between $2,000 and $4,000. If you decide to refinish the cabinets yourself, you’ll spend about $200 on materials, plus the cost of any necessary tools and time spent working on the project.

Professional cabinet refacing for an average-size kitchen typically starts at $6,000 or so, although prices fluctuate greatly depending on the door style and wood species. While refinishing or refacing cabinets isn’t cheap, it’s important to remember that a total kitchen remodel with all new cabinets starts at around $12,000 or $14,000.

Finally, cabinet refinishing is a good—and affordable—option if you want to freshen up and modernize your kitchen. However, if you want to completely transform the look of your kitchen, then choose cabinet refacing.

About the Author

Joseph Truini is a home-improvement expert and the author of the best-selling book “Building a Shed” who writes online for The Home Depot. He provides great how-to advice on upgrading the different spaces in your house. For more kitchen remodel products and information, click here.

This article is editorial content that has been contributed to HomeTips at our request and is published for the benefit of our readers. We have not been compensated for its placement.

 

 


Kitchen Cabinets

Join the Conversation

    
Share This