How to Fix a Toilet

Expert advice on how to repair toilet problems, including leaks, clogs, runs, and more.

©Don Vandervort, HomeTips

Toilet Repair – Diagram of How a Toilet Works

Toilet repair is a job that homeowners often end up tackling themselves both because toilet repairs are often reasonably simple and because they are also frequently urgent. Calling a plumber for a toilet repair usually means a high-priced emergency visit. And any delay in the plumber’s arrival can be problematic if the toilet is inoperable.

Fortunately, many toilet repairs are relatively easy for do-it-yourselfers to tackle. All you need is a basic understanding of how the toilet works, some step-by-step guidance and a few tools, such as a toilet plunger, pliers, a screwdriver, and a wrench.
If your toilet has a lazy or poor flush, see Toilet Flushes Poorly for additional tips.

Fixing a Clogged Toilet

A clog is typically cleared with a plunger or toilet auger, unless it is deep inside the drain pipes—a problem that may require a drain-clearing pro.
There are two different types of toilet clogs. The most common is a clog that simply prevents the waste and water from going down the drain. The second, and more distressing, is a clog that causes sewage to back up into a bathtub or other fixture when the toilet is flushed.

The common clog usually indicates a blockage in the pipe below or immediately adjacent to the toilet. The more serious clog usually indicates a blockage in the main drainpipe or the drainpipes beyond the area of the toilet. If your home utilizes a septic system, it may mean that the septic tank is full. (For more information, see Septic Tank Care & Maintenance.)

If your toilet is clogged but not backing up into other fixtures, don’t try to flush it or it may overflow. You can usually stop the rise of water before it overflows by lifting up the float ball or float.

1Remove the lid from the tank and raise the flapper valve to let a little water pass through so you can see whether the toilet is indeed clogged. If it is, water won’t go down the drain.

 

© Nelson Hale | Dreamstime.com

Bell-Shaped Toilet Plunger. Buy on Amazon

2If it is, first try plunging with a bell-shaped toilet plunger. Wearing rubber gloves, place the plunger’s head over the center of the toilet drain hole. Then rapidly push the plunger’s handle up and down to force air and water into the pipe, creating suction to free the clog.

If waste water drains from the toilet, you’ve probably managed to break the clog loose. Gradually pour about a gallon of water from a bucket into the toilet to flush it.

3Use a closet auger. If this doesn’t do the job, you can attempt to snake out the toilet with a closet auger (named after “water closet,” a plumbing term for toilet), which will reach down about 3 feet. Work the end of it down into the drain hole, turning the handle clockwise until the cable won’t go any further. Then push it repeatedly to dislodge the clog.

If the auger seems to have hooked onto the obstacle, try pulling it out. If it seems balky, work it back and forth carefully so as not to scratch or break the porcelain. If you are able to break through the clog, plunge the toilet again.

Toilet Drain Auger. Buy on Amazon

You can use a longer drain auger to reach a deeper clog, but you won’t be able to work it through the drain unless you remove the toilet first. (For information on how to remove and replace a toilet, see How to Install a Toilet.) Often, an easier route is to work a long plumbing auger through a nearby cleanout or vent pipe.

4Snake the main drain. If your plumbing system has a clog that is causing sewage to back up into other fixtures when the toilet is flushed, you can attempt to snake out the main drainpipes yourself with a long drain auger. (For more about how to do this, see How to Snake a Drain Clog.)

Inexpensive drain augers are available for purchase, or you can rent a high-powered model from a tool rental supplier. If this is more than you want to attempt, call a plumber or drain-clearing service.

Fixing a Toilet That Leaks at the Base

If water pools around the base of your toilet—especially during or immediately following a flush, the cause is usually a failed wax ring between the toilet’s base and the closet flange (waste pipe). If there is water beneath the toilet regardless of whether or not it has been flushed, the water may be from a leaking water supply connection or from condensation. Here is how to fix these issues.

Replace the toilet’s wax ring if the toilet is leaking at the base. Buy on Amazon

Water that pools around the base of a toilet can be caused by leaking at the seal between the toilet and the closet bend (the drainpipe beneath the floor), the seals between the tank and the bowl, the water supply tube, or because the tank is sweating. If you can’t tell whether your toilet’s tank is sweating or leaking where the tank connects to the bowl, squeeze a couple of drops of food coloring in the tank water, wait about an hour, and then dab the tank bolts with a white tissue. If the color shows up on the tissue, the tank is leaking. Otherwise, it’s probably sweating or the leak is coming from the water supply.

Replacing this ring involves pulling the toilet, so be sure the water is not coming from a leaking toilet tank or water-supply connection before you go to the trouble of replacing the wax ring.

First check for condensation on the surface (sweating). A tank typically sweats in the summer when it is cooler than the ambient air, causing moisture to condense on its surface. When the moisture drips down to the floor, it can cause mildew or—worse—dry rot. Toilet tanks can be easily insulated with a lining of foam rubber or polystyrene to prevent sweating. See below for more about fixing a toilet that sweats.

Next, look for cracks in the tank and bowl. If either the toilet tank or bowl are cracked, replace the entire toilet. For information on how to do this, see How to Install a Toilet.

Use a rag to dry the floor around the toilet’s base. Lay a newspaper beneath the toilet’s tank, wait a few minutes, and check it for drips. If there is no sign of leaking but the water reappears around the base, the wax ring is probably the culprit. If drips appear, check the fittings directly above them for leaks.

When you buy a wax ring replacement, make sure to choose one with a rubber collar, which is less likely to leak in the future. The process of replacing the wax ring is detailed in step-by-step captioned photographs in How to Install a Toilet.

Fixing a Toilet that Sweats

If water pools around the base of your toilet, one of the toilet’s seals may be leaking. But if you live in a warm, humid climate, check to see if the tank is sweating before you undertake other repairs.

toilet-drip-tray-Brass-CraftBrass Craft

Toilet drip tray catches condensation from the tank.

In humid climates, warm room air can condense on the cooler surfaces of a toilet and drip onto the floor. This encourages mold and, over time, can even rot the subflooring. The cold porcelain tank is the problem—it never warms up because, whenever the toilet is flushed, it refills with cold water. When moisture-laden warm air contacts the cold surfaces of the tank, it condenses and “sweats.” Moisture collects and drips down the tank onto the floor.

The simplest quick-fix is to buy a toilet tank drip tray that catches the drips behind the bowl. Of course, this is less than attractive and you have to empty it periodically. A better, more effective solution for a sweating toilet is to insulate it with a foam toilet tank liner, made to be glued onto the tank’s inner surfaces. Toilet tank liners are available at home improvement centers and from online suppliers.

Anti-sweat valve mixes hot water with cold. Buy on AmazonB and K

Anti-sweat valve mixes hot water with cold. Buy on Amazon

Empty the water by turning off the supply valve at the wall and flushing the toilet. Wipe down the inner walls of the tank. Cut the insulation panels to fit and attach them according to the label directions.

Replacing the tank with an insulated model can solve a toilet's sweating problem. Photo: SanifloSaniflo

Replacing the tank with an insulated model can solve a toilet’s sweating problem. Buy on Amazon

For a more permanent solution, if you have a two-piece toilet (tank is separate from the bowl), you can replace the tank with an insulated toilet tank. Be sure to get one that will work with your existing toilet model. If you can’t find a match, you can install a completely new toilet that has an insulated tank.

Another option is to talk to a plumber about installing an anti-sweat toilet tank valve on the cold water line that supplies the toilet. This draws a little hot water from a hot water pipe and mixes it with the cold water entering the toilet tank to raise the tank’s temperature. Be advised that this solution is far from ideal because it will use more energy because the water heater will need to warm the water.

Fixing a Toilet That Runs

When water runs incessantly from the tank into the bowl, typically making a hissing sound, it wastes many gallons of water every day. A running toilet can be caused by a variety of problems with the float arm, float ball, tank stopper, or inlet valve.

A toilet runs when water streams or leaks from the toilet tank into the bowl. A constantly running toilet is not only annoying but it also wastes many gallons of water every day.

A running toilet can be the result of water leaking through a poorly fitting or defective flapper or tank ball that fails to seal the flush valve between the tank and bowl, or it can be cause by water leaking into the overflow tube. For a clear understanding of what these parts are, see How a Toilet Works & Toilet Plumbing Diagrams.

Toilet Parts Diagram©Don Vandervort, HomeTips

Toilet Parts Diagram

Can you always tell if your toilet is running and wasting water? Not necessarily. Sometimes it’s obvious—the toilet makes a hissing sound or you can hear the ball cock repeatedly refilling the tank because the water level in the tank slowly drops. If you’re not sure whether your toilet is running, squeeze a few drops of food coloring into the tank to color the water. After a few minutes, if water is sneaking into the bowl from the tank, the water in the bowl will begin to turn color.

The simplest and most common remedy for a toilet that runs is to jiggle the flush handle. This is often enough to free up a flapper or float ball to properly stop the movement of water from tank to bowl.

When water refills the toilet tank after a flush, it should stop before it reaches the top of the overflow tube. Otherwise, it will continually spill down inside the tube to the bowl. To stop this type of running, you must make an adjustment that prevents the water from rising that high.

If you have a somewhat old float ball flushing mechanism, try lifting the float above water level. If water stops running, bend the float arm (the wire that holds the float ball) slightly downward so that the float ball will reach its shut-off level sooner as the water in the tank rises. The water should shut off automatically when its level is about 1/2 inch below the top of the overflow tube.

Note that the float ball may have leaked and filled up with water so it can’t float properly. To determine whether this has happened, turn off the water supply valve and flush the toilet to empty the tank. Then unscrew the ball from the float arm. You should be able to tell if it contains water by feeling its weight and shaking it. If it has water inside, replace it with a new one. Or, better still, replace the entire valve mechanism with a newer type of valve that doesn’t rely on a float ball.

Whether your toilet utilizes a rubber flapper or a tank ball to seal the flush valve between the tank and the bowl will depend on the age and type of toilet you have; tank balls used to be the standard, but flappers are more common in newer toilets.

©HomeTips

Checking toilet lift wire

If you have the older type of toilet with a tank ball, the mechanism that holds the tank ball may have become misaligned. Reach in and wiggle the tank ball to make sure it is free to move up and down directly over the flush valve. If it doesn’t move freely through its holder, try polishing it with some steel wool. Be sure the lift wires are properly connected. If this doesn’t do the trick, replace the tank ball mechanism with a flapper.

Replacement flappers made for all types of toilets are available for under $10. Flappers are particularly simple to install after you remove the old flapper or tank ball—you just slide the collar down the overflow tube, centering the flapper over the valve seat, and hook up the lift chain to the trip lever so that it has a little slack. Instructions are given on most flapper product labels.

©HomeTips

Checking toilet flapper chain

If a lift chain connects the flapper to the trip lever, check it. This often becomes kinked or snagged so that it doesn’t allow the flapper or tank ball to seat properly. If this has happened, adjust it. Also check the two rubber ears on the collar of the flapper to make sure they hinge properly on the overflow tube.

Before you actually replace a flapper or make other types of repairs inside the tank, turn off the water to the toilet at the shut-off valve located behind the toilet. Then flush the toilet once to drain the water from the tank.

After installing a new flapper, test it to make sure it flops up and down easily. Then turn the water supply shut-off valve back on to refill the toilet tank and do a test flush. If the flapper closes too quickly, check the lift chain’s length—pull it tight and then back it off one link and reattach it.

In some cases, replacing the flapper won’t fix the problem. Some toilets have a corroded flush valve seat that will continue to leak. You can try scouring the flush valve seat with steel wool or a special tool made for this purpose. Or you can replace the entire assembly, which is a considerably bigger job. Follow the instructions that come with the toilet valve seat replacement kit.

Featured Resource: Get a Pre-Screened Local Plumbing Pro

Call for free estimates from local pros now:
1-866-342-3263


Join the Conversation

  • Laurie

    My toilet is clogged and i hve tried “snaking it” soapy dawn water” drano” and plunging it and nothing has worked!!

    Do i need the “toilet auger” in order for the snake to work?

    Sometimes it will drain on its own but Its not fixed. I am so overwhelmed with this issue im ready to remove the toilet take it outside and shoot it down with a water hose or pressure washer.

    Please any suggestions

    • Tim Gatewood

      As I found out, the toilet auger is just a snake with a plastic sleeve. It did not work any better for me than the big heavy snake I already had. In fact, it worked worse, because I could not get the toilet auger in as deep as the big heavy snake. If you have tried all those other options, it is time to turn off the water to the tank, flush the tank when the bowl is empty or low to drain the tank, wait for the bowl to empty again (or use a cup or bowl to scoop out the water into a bucket or your tub), then remove the toilet from the floor. The problem is either inside the toilet and you have to go at it from the bottom or it is in the pipe.

      Please note: I am not a plumber. I am going strictly on the basis of my own recent experiences. Unless you are pretty strong, I don’t recommend trying to lift the toilet off the bolts that attach it to the the flange without help. And be sure you have towels ready to set the toilet on, as any water still inside it is going to come out at some point, especially if you snake it again from the bottom.

      Good luck.

  • Bill Hurley

    I have a new toilet that works fine and no apparent leaks either. However it squeaks (horn sound almost) after each flush. What could that be?

Share This